Retainer overage: billing hours over the allowance
Bill overage at a rate and notice you set before month one, and warn the client at mid-month, not on the invoice. In the example, 9 hours over leaves US$1,155 of contribution unbilled and US$2,145 billed.
A client's retainer covers 30 hours a month. They used 39. Do you bill the 9 extra hours, at what rate, and how do you send that invoice without an argument?
This guide sets out the overage rule to agree before month one, a pace check that turns a surprise into a choice, and a fictional studio's month under four choices. The method works for hourly retainers. Contract wording is for your lawyer.
Decide the overage rule before month one
Three points make overage billable and keep it calm. Agree all three in writing.
- The rate. Start from the retainer's fee per hour. How to price a monthly retainer shows how to set an overage rate at your target margin.
- The increment. The smallest unit you bill, such as a quarter hour. Set it once so no one argues over a few minutes.
- The notice. When you tell the client, and what you need back. A good rule is a written yes before any hour past the allowance is worked.
Four formulas cover the rest:
Fee per hour = monthly fee ÷ included hours
Overage amount = overage hours × overage rate
Contribution = fee + overage billed − (hours worked × internal hourly cost)
Projected month hours = hours used so far × working days in month ÷ working days gone
Contribution here means before overhead. Contribution is the fee and overage billed less the cost of the hours worked. Your internal hourly cost is what an hour of your team's time costs you, not what you charge.
A premium rate is a choice. Billing at the fee per hour keeps the margin the retainer was priced at. Billing at 1.25 times pays for the disruption of fitting extra work in. Either works if the client agreed to it first.
The mid-month pace check
Overage is a surprise only if the first number the client sees is on the invoice. Check pace at the middle of the month, when half the working days are gone and half remain.
- Count the hours used so far and the working days gone.
- Project the month: hours used × working days in month ÷ working days gone.
- If the projection is over the allowance, write to the client that day.
The message holds four things: hours used, hours left, the projected total, and the choices. The client can approve the extra hours at the stated rate, hold to the allowance by moving work to next month, or cut scope.
Early days are noisy, so a projection in the first week misleads. Retainer burn explains why the middle of the month is the checkpoint, and how to adjust for retainers whose work comes early.
A worked example (fictional)
Fictional example. Pennant Row Studio is not a real business. The figures are illustrative and are not a customer result.
Pennant Row Studio is a four-person web and content studio that bills in US dollars. Its internal hourly cost is US$55. One client, a property management company, pays US$3,300 a month for 30 hours of site care. The fee per hour is US$3,300 ÷ 30 = US$110.
The month has 22 working days. After 11 of them the client has used 21 hours.
- Projected month hours: 21 × 22 ÷ 11 = 42.
- Projected overage: 42 − 30 = 12 hours.
- Run-out: 21 hours in 11 days is 1.91 hours a day, so 30 hours are reached on working day 16 (21 × 16 ÷ 11 = 30.5).
The studio writes to the client that day with the choices. The client approves extra hours at US$110, up to 12. In the end the month uses 39 hours. That is 9 over, less than the 12 projected.
The cost of 39 hours is 39 × US$55 = US$2,145. Here is the month under each choice:
| Choice | Hours worked | Overage billed | Fee | Cost | Contribution | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Held to 30 hours | 30 | US$0 | US$3,300 | US$1,650 | US$1,650 | 50.0% |
| 39 hours, overage absorbed | 39 | US$0 | US$3,300 | US$2,145 | US$1,155 | 35.0% |
| 39 hours, overage at US$110 | 39 | US$990 | US$4,290 | US$2,145 | US$2,145 | 50.0% |
| 39 hours, overage at 1.25 times | 39 | US$1,237.50 | US$4,537.50 | US$2,145 | US$2,392.50 | 52.7% |
The arithmetic:
- Held: cost 30 × US$55 = US$1,650. Contribution US$3,300 − US$1,650 = US$1,650, which is US$1,650 ÷ US$3,300 = 50.0%.
- Absorbed: US$3,300 − US$2,145 = US$1,155. Margin US$1,155 ÷ US$3,300 = 35.0%.
- At US$110: 9 × US$110 = US$990. Revenue US$3,300 + US$990 = US$4,290. Contribution US$4,290 − US$2,145 = US$2,145, or US$2,145 ÷ US$4,290 = 50.0%.
- At 1.25 times: the rate is 1.25 × US$110 = US$137.50. 9 × US$137.50 = US$1,237.50. Revenue US$3,300 + US$1,237.50 = US$4,537.50. Contribution US$4,537.50 − US$2,145 = US$2,392.50, or US$2,392.50 ÷ US$4,537.50 = 52.7%.
Reading the result
- Absorbing the overage costs 15.0 points of margin. The 9 hours cost 9 × US$55 = US$495, and US$495 ÷ US$3,300 = 15.0%. Contribution drops from US$1,650 to US$1,155.
- Billing at the fee per hour restores the priced margin. It lands at 50.0%, the same as the held month. The extra US$990 is exactly the contribution the studio would have lost.
- The client's effective rate falls if you absorb. US$3,300 for 39 hours is US$84.62 an hour worked, not US$110. The client learns the lower price and expects it.
- The invoice is 30.0% bigger than usual. US$990 ÷ US$3,300 = 30.0%. That is why the pace check goes out at mid-month, not at invoice time.
- A premium needs a reason. The 1.25 rate adds US$247.50 over the standard rate, which is 9 × US$27.50. Use it where extra hours displace other work, and say so in the contract.
One month is a small sample. The month's overage tells you about this month, not about the client.
Billing it
The invoice is where the rule meets the client. Keep it plain.
- A separate line. The retainer fee on one line, the overage on another: "Overage: 9 hours at US$110, US$990". The total is US$3,300 + US$990 = US$4,290.
- The time log attached. List the hours past the allowance by date and task, so no one has to ask.
- The same invoice date. Send it when the retainer invoice would go out. A late overage invoice reads as an afterthought.
- The approval cited. Name the message where the client approved the extra hours.
Whether sales tax applies to the overage line is a question for your accountant.
When overage repeats three months running
One month over is a spike. Three in a row is a sizing problem, and rebilling it each month wears the relationship down. When to reprice, rescope or drop a client shows how to decide.
Say the client used 39, 37 and 41 hours over three months. Overage is 9, 7 and 11 hours, which is 27 in all. Billed at US$110, that is 27 × US$110 = US$2,970. Three months of fees bring in 3 × US$3,300 = US$9,900, so US$9,900 + US$2,970 = US$12,870.
The average month is 117 ÷ 3 = 39 hours. Resize to 39 hours at US$110, and the fee is 39 × US$110 = US$4,290 a month, or 3 × US$4,290 = US$12,870 over the same three months. The studio bills the same total. The client gets one steady number instead of three invoices. The 117 hours cost 117 × US$55 = US$6,435 either way, so contribution is US$12,870 − US$6,435 = US$6,435 (50.0%). Absorbed, it would be US$9,900 − US$6,435 = US$3,465 (35.0%).
Resizing is a price decision. Read several months before you make it. If use swings month to month, rollover rules may fit better than a bigger allowance.
Value and deliverable retainers
Not every retainer sells hours. A value retainer sells a fixed scope, and a deliverables retainer sells outputs such as a set of posts. The hours are a guide to cost, not what the client bought.
You don't bill overage on these. You absorb the hours, and the question is whether the retainer still pays. In the example, the same 9 hours over a 30-hour guide cost US$495, which is 15.0 points of margin. Track the hours absorbed each month. When they repeat, re-scope or reprice at renewal.
What this doesn't do
- It doesn't write the contract. Overage terms, notice and what happens to disputed hours are for a lawyer.
- It doesn't set tax treatment, such as sales tax on the overage line. Ask your accountant.
- It uses one internal hourly cost, so every hour costs the same whoever delivers it.
- The pace check assumes work arrives evenly through the month. A retainer with a fixed report on the 5th needs a front-loaded curve.
- It looks at one client. Several clients going over together is a capacity question: count free hours by person, as in how to set a realistic utilization target.
- It stops before overhead, and says nothing about cash or when the client pays.
A planner for this
The formulas above work in any spreadsheet. The Retainer Burn & Capacity Planner covers the pace check for each active retainer. It takes the hours you have used so far, carries the same pace over the working days left, and shows projected hours left and a run-out date.
For an hourly retainer with an overage rate entered, it shows the projected overage hours and the amount. For a value retainer it shows the hours over, with no amount. It doesn't bill the overage, and it doesn't record time. You type in hours you have already tracked. Entry is manual, and the workbook is tested in Excel 365 for Windows desktop.
Sources and method
Every figure in this guide comes from the fictional worked example (Pennant Row Studio). The pace projection, the overage amounts, the contribution and the margins are the arithmetic shown above. No contract, regulator or statistic is cited. What the planner does is described from its product page.
Common questions
Should I charge a client for hours over their retainer?
Usually yes, if the contract says overage is billable and the client heard about it before the hours were worked. Hours you absorb come out of your contribution: in the example, 9 unbilled hours cost US$495. If the client never agreed to overage, treat the first month as a conversation, then set the rule. Ask a lawyer about the wording.
What rate should I charge for retainer overage?
The retainer's fee per hour is the floor: fee divided by included hours. Billed at that rate, each extra hour keeps the margin the retainer was priced at. Some studios charge a premium, such as 1.25 times, for work that displaces other clients. Put the rate in the contract before the first month.
How do I tell a client they are going over their retainer hours?
Send the pace check at mid-month: hours used, hours left, the projected total, and the choices. Offer to approve the extra hours at the stated rate, hold to the allowance by moving work, or cut scope. Ask for a reply in writing before the hours are worked. Then the invoice is no surprise.
How we research, check and update these guides. Found an error? Email [email protected] and we’ll correct it and note the change here.