Unused retainer hours: roll over, expire or cap?
Carry unused hours over only as far as you can deliver them. In the example, four quiet months bank 45 hours under full rollover and 16 under a cap. Settle the rule before month one.
A client used 22 of their 35 retainer hours this month and asks to keep the other 13. Do retainer hours roll over? That is a rule you set, and it is a promise about your team's time.
This guide sets out three rules for unused hours and what each promises. A fictional studio runs all three over four quiet months and prices the promise at cost and at fee value. Contract wording is for your lawyer, and the accounting is for your accountant.
Three rules, and what each promises
Expire. Unused hours lapse at month end. Each month starts fresh. You promise nothing beyond the current month.
Roll over in full. Unused hours carry forward with no limit. Each quiet month adds to a balance the client can call on later. The promise has no ceiling.
Capped rollover. Unused hours carry forward up to a limit. Two settings set it: the most hours banked in a month, and how long a banked hour stays usable. The promise has a ceiling.
A banked hour is an hour the client has paid for and you have not delivered. You may owe it in a month you can't yet see. Four formulas size the promise:
Fee per hour = monthly fee ÷ included hours
Hours on offer = included hours + banked hours still usable
Promise at fee value = banked hours × fee per hour
Promise at cost = banked hours × internal hourly cost
Your internal hourly cost is what an hour of your team's time costs you, not what you charge. How to set an internal hourly cost rate shows how to find it. Contribution is the fee less the cost of the hours delivered, before overhead. Client profitability: contribution before overhead explains it with a worked month.
Choosing a rule
Four questions decide the rule, in this order.
- What does the retainer sell? Some retainers sell availability: a slice of your team held for the client each month. Others sell a quantity of hours. Availability fits expiry, because the slice was held whether or not the client used it. A quantity of hours fits rollover better. Decide which you sell, and say so in the contract.
- Is the client's use lumpy or low? List the hours used in the last three or four months. If the busiest month is under the allowance, rollover won't help: the retainer is bigger than the client's need, and the resize section below applies. If some months run over and others under, rollover solves a real problem.
- How much slack can you hold? In your busiest month, how many hours beyond the allowance could you give this client? That is the most the bank should hold. How to set a realistic utilization target shows how to count your available hours.
- How long can a banked hour live? An hour banked in January and called on in June comes due when you may be busy. A short life, such as two months, keeps the promise within a period you can plan for.
With little slack, expire, or cap the bank at a few hours. With lumpy use and some slack, cap the bank and give each hour a life. Full rollover is safe only if you could deliver the whole bank in one month.
A worked example (fictional)
Fictional example. Thornley Wharf Studio is not a real business. The figures are illustrative and are not a customer result.
Thornley Wharf Studio is a five-person web studio that bills in US dollars. Its internal hourly cost is US$55. One client, an online outdoor shop, pays US$3,500 a month for 35 hours of site care. The fee per hour is US$3,500 ÷ 35 = US$100.
The client used 22, 25, 28 and 20 hours over four months. Unused hours are 35 − 22 = 13, then 10, 7 and 15, which is 45 hours in all. The studio compares three rules:
- Expire: unused hours lapse each month.
- Full rollover: every unused hour carries forward, with no limit.
- Capped rollover: up to 9 unused hours a month are banked. A banked hour is usable for the next two months, then it lapses.
The client always spends the month's own hours first. It never goes above 35 in these four months, so no banked hour is spent. Here are the banks:
| Month | Hours used | Unused | Full: bank | Capped: banked | Capped: lapsed | Capped: bank |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 22 | 13 | 13 | 9 | 0 | 9 |
| 2 | 25 | 10 | 23 | 9 | 0 | 18 |
| 3 | 28 | 7 | 30 | 7 | 9 | 16 |
| 4 | 20 | 15 | 45 | 9 | 9 | 16 |
| Total | 95 | 45 | 34 | 18 |
Full rollover adds each month's unused hours to the bank: 13, then 13 + 10 = 23, 23 + 7 = 30 and 30 + 15 = 45. The capped rule banks the smaller of the unused hours and 9. In month 3 it banks 7, and the 9 hours banked in month 1 lapse, so the bank is 18 + 7 − 9 = 16. In month 4 it banks 9, and the 9 hours from month 2 lapse: 16 + 9 − 9 = 16.
What the bank promises in month 5. After its other work, the studio can give this client 40 hours in month 5. That is an assumption of the example. Hours on offer are 35 plus the bank. Each banked hour is US$100 of fee the client has paid, and US$55 of cost if you deliver it.
| Rule | Banked hours | Hours on offer | Short of 40 | At fee value | At cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Expire | 0 | 35 | 0 | US$0 | US$0 |
| Capped | 16 | 51 | 11 | US$1,600 | US$880 |
| Full | 45 | 80 | 40 | US$4,500 | US$2,475 |
Capped: 35 + 16 = 51 hours on offer, with 16 × US$100 = US$1,600 of fee and 16 × US$55 = US$880 of cost owed. Full: 35 + 45 = 80 hours, with 45 × US$100 = US$4,500 and 45 × US$55 = US$2,475. Under expiry, the studio has 5 hours to spare.
What each rule does to contribution if the client uses every hour on offer. This is the most each rule can ask of the studio, not a forecast. The fee is US$3,500 a month under all three rules.
| Rule | Hours in month 5 | Cost at US$55 | Month 5 contribution | Month 5 margin | Five-month contribution |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Expire | 35 | US$1,925 | US$1,575 | 45.0% | US$10,350 |
| Capped | 51 | US$2,805 | US$695 | 19.9% | US$9,470 |
| Full | 80 | US$4,400 | −US$900 | −25.7% | US$7,875 |
The arithmetic for full rollover:
- Cost in month 5: 80 × US$55 = US$4,400.
- Contribution: US$3,500 − US$4,400 = −US$900.
- Margin: −US$900 ÷ US$3,500 = −25.7%.
- Five months of fees: 5 × US$3,500 = US$17,500.
- Hours: 95 + 80 = 175, which cost 175 × US$55 = US$9,625.
- Five-month contribution: US$17,500 − US$9,625 = US$7,875, which is 45.0% of the fees.
The expire and capped rows work the same way, with 130 and 146 hours over the five months.
Reading the result
- Expiry keeps the most contribution. The studio ends the five months with US$10,350, or 59.1% of the fees. It keeps the fee for every unused hour.
- Full rollover returns the priced margin only if you deliver the whole bank. The priced margin is US$3,500 − 35 × US$55 = US$1,575, or 45.0%. Full rollover lands exactly there, at 45.0%, but only if the studio delivers 80 hours in month 5. It can give 40.
- A cap makes the gap smaller, not zero. It cuts the shortfall from 40 hours to 11 and the cost of the bank from US$2,475 to US$880. To close the gap, set the bank from your slack: 40 − 35 = 5 hours. Month 5 then offers 35 + 5 = 40 hours, which fits.
- Keep banked hours out of hours used. They are hours you owe, not hours worked. If they sit in the same column, the month's pace misleads you. Retainer burn shows how to read pace from hours used.
One client over four months is a small sample. Test any rule against your busiest month, not your quietest.
When underuse means the retainer is too big
A rollover rule answers whether the client keeps the hours. It doesn't ask why they went unused. In the example the client used 95 of 140 hours, which is 95 ÷ 140 = 67.9%. Its busiest month was 28 hours, 7 under the allowance. No rollover rule is needed to serve that client. The retainer is bigger than the need.
From the client's side, four months cost US$14,000 for 95 hours. That is US$14,000 ÷ 95 = US$147.37 for each hour used, not US$100. You have three moves:
- Resize to 30 hours at the same US$100 an hour. The fee falls to US$3,000, and every month still fits, because 28 is under 30. Four months bring in US$12,000 for 95 hours, which is US$126.32 an hour used. The 95 hours cost 95 × US$55 = US$5,225 either way. Your contribution falls from US$14,000 − US$5,225 = US$8,775 (62.7%) to US$12,000 − US$5,225 = US$6,775 (56.5%), which is US$2,000 less.
- Keep 35 hours and cap the bank. You keep the fee and take on a promise with a ceiling.
- Keep 35 hours and let hours expire. You keep the fee, and the question stays open at renewal.
Resizing is a price decision. Read several months of figures before you make it. When to reprice, rescope or drop a client shows how to decide and how to raise it.
Write the rule down before month one
A rule written after the client has banked 30 hours is a negotiation. Write it first, and cover these points:
- Which hours roll: unused included hours only, or also hours the client bought on top.
- The cap: the most hours banked in a month, and the most the bank can hold.
- The life: how many months a banked hour stays usable.
- The order: the month's own hours first, then the oldest banked hours.
- The ending: what happens to the bank if the retainer ends or pauses. Ask your lawyer.
- The record: who logs banked hours, and when. Month close keeps it to one entry per retainer.
Put the same words in the contract, and have your lawyer read them.
Unused hours in your accounts
If a client pays in advance for hours you haven't delivered, US revenue accounting treats the prepayment as a contract liability until you deliver the work. The standard calls the part customers never use breakage, and it sets rules for when expected breakage becomes revenue.
Whether a monthly retainer is that kind of prepayment, and how to treat hours that lapse, is your accountant's call. The standard is cited only to show the question exists.
What this method doesn't do
- It doesn't set your accounting treatment. Ask your accountant.
- It doesn't write the contract, or say what a client can claim if a retainer ends with hours banked. Ask a lawyer.
- It assumes the client spends the month's own hours first and never goes over 35. A client who goes over and then draws on the bank changes the bank and the cost figures.
- The contribution table assumes the client uses every hour on offer in month 5. Most months won't. It is a ceiling, not a forecast.
- It uses one internal hourly cost, so every hour costs the same whoever delivers it.
- It looks at one client. Several clients calling on their banks in the same month is a team question: count the free hours each person has.
- It stops before overhead, and says nothing about cash or when you bill.
A planner for this
The Retainer Burn & Capacity Planner holds a rollover rule for each retainer: none, next month only, or carry forward, with an optional cap. It shows the rollover that rule suggests, and you log the hours you agreed with the client. It never carries hours forward on its own.
The month's hours available are the included hours plus the rolled-over hours you log, and projected hours left is measured against that total. Log rolled-over hours apart from hours used, so the pace stays honest.
The planner's rules are those three. The example's two-month life is not one of them, so work out that figure yourself and log it. The planner takes hours you have already tracked, and it doesn't record time. Retainer periods are calendar months, entry is manual, and the workbook is tested in Excel 365 for Windows desktop. The method above works in any spreadsheet.
Independence
Metricvalley is independent. This guide isn't affiliated with, or endorsed by, the Financial Accounting Standards Board. Nothing in this guide is accounting, tax or legal advice.
Sources and method
Every figure in the worked example is fictional (Thornley Wharf Studio). The banks, the promise at fee value and at cost, and the contribution figures are the arithmetic shown above. The accounting points are paraphrased from the update below, which issued the Topic 606 paragraphs on customers' unexercised rights (606-10-55-46 to 55-49). An update isn't authoritative: the FASB Accounting Standards Codification, as amended since, is. Your accountant works from the Codification.
- Financial Accounting Standards Board, Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09, Revenue from Contracts with Customers (Topic 606), Section A (issued May 2014), read Nov 3, 2026.
Common questions
Should unused retainer hours roll over?
Only as far as you can deliver them. If the client's use is lumpy and you have slack, cap the bank and how long a banked hour stays usable. If you sell availability, let hours expire and say so in the contract. Full rollover suits a retainer you could deliver in one month at any size. In the example, a cap held a 45-hour bank to 16.
How big should a rollover cap be?
No bigger than the spare hours you have for that client in your busiest month. If you could give a 35-hour client 40 hours, the bank can hold 5. Then give each banked hour a life, such as two months. A cap is a promise you can keep, not a share of the fee.
Can a client get money back for unused retainer hours?
That depends on your contract and on the law where you and the client are, so ask a lawyer. A retainer that says unused hours lapse says so in its own terms. How your accounts treat prepaid hours that go unused is your accountant's call. Either way, write the rule down before the first month.
How we research, check and update these guides. Found an error? Email [email protected] and we’ll correct it and note the change here.