Why track time on fixed-fee and retainer work?

Track hours because a fixed fee hides them, and they tell clients apart. Two clients paying US$6,000 a month can leave US$70.00 and US$18.17 an hour. Log client, project and week in 15-minute steps, and check the gaps monthly.

You don't bill by the hour. Each client pays a fixed fee or a monthly retainer, so the invoice never shows how long the work took. Logging hours can feel like paperwork for a number nobody pays for.

This guide shows what that number tells you that fees can't. It then sets out the least you can log, a five-minute weekly habit and a monthly check. A fictional studio works through each step. A last section covers time records the law may require, which are a separate matter.

What hours show that a fixed fee hides

A fee tells you what a client pays. It says nothing about what the work took. Two clients on the same fee can need very different amounts of your team's time, and only the hours show it.

Contribution before overhead is a client's fee, less outside costs and the cost of the hours spent on it, before shared running costs. Client profitability: contribution before overhead explains it with a worked month. Your internal hourly cost is what an hour of your team's time costs you, not what you charge. How to set an internal hourly cost rate shows how to find it.

Contribution          = fee − outside costs − hours × internal hourly cost
Contribution per hour = contribution ÷ hours

Fees are on your invoices and outside costs are on supplier bills. Hours are the one input you have to collect on purpose. Without them, neither line can be worked out.

A retainer with included hours gives a second reason. You can only see how much of the allowance you have used if you have counted it, and a month that has closed is too late to act. Retainer burn shows how to read that pace from the hours logged so far.

The least you can track

Log less than a timesheet and more than a guess. Four steps do it.

Step 1: Log client, project, week and hours

Each person adds one line per client project per week. A line holds four things: who, which client project, which week, and hours in 15-minute steps. A client project is one piece of work, such as "Website care" or "Paid search". A retainer is one project.

Add one code for internal time, so every available hour has a home. The gap check in step 4 needs it. Split it into sales and admin only if you want to see them apart.

If a week spans two months, put it in the month it ends in. Write the rule down and keep it.

Step 2: Count every hour that serves the client

Count calls, reviews, account management, revision rounds and fixes. Count your own hours too. If you work alone, your hours are the whole log. Hours you leave out don't disappear. They make the client they belonged to look better than it was.

Step 3: Take five minutes on Friday

Block the same slot every week. Fill the week from your calendar, sent mail and project board, and round each line to 15 minutes. Budget five minutes a person. If it takes much longer, group lines by client project, not by task.

This is less exact than logging as you go. It is enough to tell a client that leaves US$70.00 an hour from one that leaves US$18.17. It is too coarse to bill by the hour. For a retainer with a cap, also compare the week's running total with the share of the month gone.

Step 4: Check the gaps once a month

For each person, compare hours logged with hours available. Available hours are contracted hours less holidays and leave. How to set a realistic utilization target shows how to count them, and runs a fuller monthly check.

Gap           = available hours − logged hours
Logged share  = logged hours ÷ available hours

Pick a floor and flag anyone below it. The floor is yours to set. The example below uses 90%.

What you can leave out

  • Notes on each line.
  • A start-stop clock.
  • A billable flag on each line.
  • Entries finer than 15 minutes.
  • A separate time tool, if a calendar and a spreadsheet already hold what you need.

Add detail only when a decision needs it. If you plan to bill for extra requests, tag those hours. If your people's costs differ a lot, log by role.

A worked example (fictional)

Fictional example. Ostler Row Studio is not a real business. The figures are illustrative and are not a customer result.

Ostler Row Studio is a four-person design and web studio that bills in US dollars. Its internal hourly cost is US$55 for everyone. Two of its clients pay a fixed US$6,000 a month, and neither has outside costs. Client A is a veterinary clinic group on a content and SEO retainer. Client B is an online furniture retailer on website care and paid search.

Without hours, the two look the same. Each pays US$6,000, and each is half of the US$12,000 they pay together.

Here is October, after four Friday logs:

Client Project Week 1 Week 2 Week 3 Week 4 Month
A Content and SEO retainer 11.5 13.25 10.75 12.5 48
B Website care 6 7.5 8.25 8.25 30
B Paid search 12.75 14 15 10.25 52
Total 30.25 34.75 34 31 130

Client B's hours are 30 + 52 = 82. Now each client for the month:

Client Fee Hours Cost at US$55 Contribution Margin Per hour
A US$6,000 48 US$2,640 US$3,360 56.0% US$70.00
B US$6,000 82 US$4,510 US$1,490 24.8% US$18.17
Total US$12,000 130 US$7,150 US$4,850 40.4% US$37.31

The arithmetic for client B:

  • Cost of hours: 82 × US$55 = US$4,510.
  • Contribution: US$6,000 − US$4,510 = US$1,490.
  • Margin: US$1,490 ÷ US$6,000 = 24.8%.
  • Contribution per hour: US$1,490 ÷ 82 = US$18.17.

For client A: 48 × US$55 = US$2,640, so contribution is US$6,000 − US$2,640 = US$3,360. That is 56.0% of the fee, or US$3,360 ÷ 48 = US$70.00 an hour.

Client B takes 63.1% of the hours (82 of 130) and leaves 30.7% of the contribution (US$1,490 of US$4,850). The project column says where to look first. Paid search took 52 of B's 82 hours, or 63.4%.

The log has a cost too. Five minutes for each of four people over four weeks is 4 × 5 × 4 = 80 minutes. At US$55 an hour, that is 80 ÷ 60 × US$55 = US$73.33. The two clients' contribution differs by US$3,360 − US$1,490 = US$1,870 a month. The fees never showed it.

Now the monthly gap check. Ostler Row's four people had these available hours for October, after holidays and leave:

Person Available Logged Gap Logged share
Designer 150 138 12 92.0%
Developer 156 149 7 95.5%
Writer 120 118 2 98.3%
Owner 140 91 49 65.0%
Total 566 496 70 87.6%

Only the owner is below the 90% floor. The owner's 49 missing hours are more than the 34 hours between B (82) and A (48). If all 49 had been client A's, A would have taken 97 hours and left US$665, or US$6.86 an hour. That is below B. The gap could have reversed the result.

The owner checks the calendar and finds 41 of the 49 hours: 19 hours of sales calls and 22 of admin and hiring. All are internal. Logged hours rise to 91 + 41 = 132, which is 94.3% of 140. Eight hours stay unexplained. That is far fewer than the 34 hours between the clients, so the order of A and B holds.

Reading the result

A weekly log can be rough. The decision here survives error. Take B's hours 15 under and 15 over what was logged, with A unchanged:

Client B's hours Cost at US$55 Contribution Margin Per hour
67 US$3,685 US$2,315 38.6% US$34.55
82 US$4,510 US$1,490 24.8% US$18.17
97 US$5,335 US$665 11.1% US$6.86

Even at 67 hours, B leaves about half of A's US$70.00 an hour. A 15-hour error moves B's figure a lot but not its place below A. A 49-hour gap, as in the check above, could change the order. Close any large gap before you act on a close call.

One month is one data point. Read three months before you change a price. A busy month for a client can be a launch or a one-off.

Then pick a move for B.

  • Reprice at renewal, to the hours the work needs.
  • Rescope: agree what the fee covers, such as fewer paid search changes a month.
  • Bill the extras: agree a rate for extra requests, and quote them before the work starts.

When to reprice, rescope or drop a client shows how to choose between them and how to raise a price.

Time records the law may require anyway

This is a separate purpose from pricing. In the US, the Fair Labor Standards Act has recordkeeping rules for covered employers. The Department of Labor's fact sheet lists records to keep for each non-exempt worker, including the hours worked each day and the total hours worked each workweek.

The fact sheet says the law requires no particular form. It also says the information must be accurate, and that any timekeeping plan is acceptable as long as it is complete and accurate.

A weekly log built for pricing records hours by client project, not by day, and it is filled in after the week ends. Don't treat it as your payroll record. Which of your staff are non-exempt is a legal question. Ask an employment adviser or your accountant, and ask whether state rules add anything. If you keep daily hours for payroll, ask whether the same entries can feed your project log, so nobody types them twice.

What this method doesn't do

  • It sees only the hours people log. A week filled in on Friday is less exact than logging as you go, and unlogged work flatters the client it belonged to.
  • It uses one internal hourly cost for everyone. If B's work falls to your most expensive people, B is worse than shown.
  • It shows where hours went, not whether they were well spent. Don't use it to rank people.
  • It stops before overhead. Rent, software and admin time still come out of the contribution.
  • It looks back at closed weeks and months. It doesn't forecast what a client will pay.
  • It isn't a legal timekeeping record. The section above says who to ask.
  • It is management arithmetic, not your accounts. For how fees and costs appear in your books, or any tax question, ask your accountant.

Where the tracker fits

The Client Profitability Tracker records fees, credits, delivery hours and delivery costs for each client project by month. It shows contribution before overhead, margin and contribution per delivery hour, with contribution by client for the month you pick. Negative results stay visible. A row with missing details is marked Review and left out of the totals until you fix it.

It is not a time-tracking tool. It takes no weekly entries and no start-stop clock, and it doesn't compare hours logged with hours available. Total your weekly log by client project, then type one row per client project per month. Each row uses one internal hourly cost, so hours are not split by person. Entry is manual. The workbook is tested in Excel 365 for Windows desktop, and like this guide it stops before overhead. The formulas above work in any spreadsheet.

Independence

Metricvalley is independent. This guide isn't affiliated with, or endorsed by, the U.S. Department of Labor. Nothing in this guide is legal, tax or financial advice.

Sources and method

Every figure in the worked example is fictional (Ostler Row Studio). Contribution and contribution per hour apply the contribution-margin idea, revenue minus the costs that move with the work, to each client's hours. The gap check, the error table and the cost of the log are the arithmetic set out above. The recordkeeping points come from the Department of Labor fact sheet below, which summarizes the Fair Labor Standards Act's recordkeeping regulations (29 CFR Part 516).

Common questions

How detailed does time tracking need to be on fixed-fee work?

Client, project and week, in 15-minute steps. That is enough to compare clients and to see where a project's hours went. Task notes, billable flags and a start-stop clock add effort without changing many decisions. Add detail only when a decision needs it, such as tagging extra requests so you can bill for them.

Do owners and part-time staff need to log time too?

Yes. Owner hours get left out, and leaving them out makes every client look better than it is. Part-time staff log the same way. The monthly gap check compares each person's logged hours with that person's own available hours, so it works for both.

Does a project time log meet US wage-hour record rules?

Not necessarily. The Department of Labor says employers keep hours records for each non-exempt worker, that the information must be accurate, and that any timekeeping plan must be complete and accurate. A weekly log built for pricing may not meet that. Ask an employment adviser which of your staff it covers.

How we research, check and update these guides. Found an error? Email [email protected] and we’ll correct it and note the change here.

All guides