When does a new client start paying? Onboarding payback

A new client has paid back when its running total reaches zero. The total starts at minus the pitch and onboarding cost, and each month adds that month's contribution. In the worked example that is month 4, or month 3 with an onboarding fee.

A new client costs hours before it pays anything. The proposal takes a week. Onboarding takes another. The first month's work runs long. When does the client start paying for all of it?

This guide shows how to find out. Price the pitch and onboarding hours at cost. Add each month's contribution to a running total. The first month the total reaches zero or more is the payback month. A fictional studio works through every step, and its payback month is month 4. Then it tests a minimum term and an onboarding fee, and checks a client list.

What a new client costs before the first invoice

Three kinds of hours come before a new client's steady months:

  • Pitch hours: calls, research and the proposal, before the client says yes.
  • Onboarding hours: the kickoff, access, an audit, and setting up tools and reports, after the client says yes.
  • Settling hours: extra delivery hours in the first months, while your team learns the client. These sit inside each month's delivery hours.

Price each hour at your internal hourly cost. That is what an hour of that person's time costs you, not what you charge. How to set an internal hourly cost rate shows how to find it. A senior person who writes the proposal may cost more an hour than the person who onboards. Use each person's own rate.

Upfront cost         = pitch hours × cost rate
                       + onboarding hours × cost rate
                       + outside costs of getting started
Monthly contribution = fee − outside costs − delivery hours × cost rate

Monthly contribution is contribution before overhead: what is left after delivery costs, before rent, software and admin. Client profitability: contribution before overhead explains it with a worked month. Outside costs of getting started are things like a contractor's setup invoice, or a tool you buy for this client alone.

How payback is counted

Payback asks how long a project takes to recover its upfront cost. OpenStax's managerial accounting text describes it that way. When the amounts differ from period to period, you add each period's amount until the cost is recovered. Then you take the part of the last period that you needed: what was still outstanding, divided by that period's amount.

A new client fits: the upfront cost comes first, and the contribution that follows is uneven.

Running total after month n = contribution in months 1 to n − upfront cost
Payback month               = first month the running total is zero or more
Part of the month           = shortfall after the month before ÷ that month's contribution
Months to payback           = full months before + part of the month

Payback ignores what the client pays afterward. The limits are near the end.

How to find the payback month

Step 1: Add up the hours before the first invoice

Use your time log. If you did not log pitch time, estimate it from your calendar and mark it as an estimate. Price pitch and onboarding each at its own rate. Add any outside costs.

Step 2: Forecast each month's contribution

For each of the first months, take the fee, take off outside costs, and take off expected delivery hours times your cost rate. Guess the hours from your last few new clients. In the example below, the first two months take more hours than the rest. Yours may differ, so check.

Step 3: Keep a running total

Start at minus the upfront cost. Add each month's contribution. Stop at the first month the total is zero or more.

Step 4: Work out the part of the month

Divide the shortfall at the end of the month before by that month's contribution. Treat the result as a guide, not a date. It assumes the contribution arrives evenly through the month.

A worked example (fictional)

Fictional example. Larkmoor Studio is not a real business. The figures are illustrative and are not a customer result.

Larkmoor is a five-person web and content studio. It wins a new client, a veterinary group, on a US$3,500 monthly retainer. There are no outside costs. Larkmoor's internal hourly cost for delivery is US$55.

The upfront hours:

  • Pitch: 24 hours at US$70, because the owner and a senior designer wrote the proposal. 24 × US$70 = US$1,680.
  • Onboarding: 40 hours at US$55. 40 × US$55 = US$2,200.
  • Upfront cost: US$1,680 + US$2,200 = US$3,880.

The table treats all 64 hours as one cost that comes before month 1, even if some of the onboarding falls inside it.

Delivery takes 55 hours in month 1, 45 in month 2, and 30 a month from month 3. Each month's contribution is the fee less the hours at US$55:

  • Month 1: US$3,500 − 55 × US$55 = US$3,500 − US$3,025 = US$475.
  • Month 2: US$3,500 − 45 × US$55 = US$3,500 − US$2,475 = US$1,025.
  • Month 3 onward: US$3,500 − 30 × US$55 = US$3,500 − US$1,650 = US$1,850.
Month Hours Fee Cost of hours Contribution Running total
Before month 1 64 US$0 US$3,880 −US$3,880 −US$3,880
1 55 US$3,500 US$3,025 US$475 −US$3,405
2 45 US$3,500 US$2,475 US$1,025 −US$2,380
3 30 US$3,500 US$1,650 US$1,850 −US$530
4 30 US$3,500 US$1,650 US$1,850 US$1,320

Each running total adds the month's contribution to the one above it. For month 4, −US$530 + US$1,850 = US$1,320.

After month 3, Larkmoor is still US$530 short. Month 4 contributes US$1,850, so payback comes in month 4. The part of the month is US$530 ÷ US$1,850 = 0.29. Months to payback: 3 + 0.29 = 3.29.

Month 1 alone shows a margin of 13.6% (US$475 ÷ US$3,500). The table shows what the client cost to win.

Test a minimum term and an onboarding fee

Two terms in the contract can move the result. A minimum term sets how many months the client must stay. An onboarding fee is a one-off charge for the setup.

For each length of stay, the table shows where the running total ends with no fee. It also shows the fee that would bring it to zero.

Client leaves after Running total, no fee Fee that brings it to zero
1 month −US$3,405 US$3,405
2 months −US$2,380 US$2,380
3 months −US$530 US$530
4 months US$1,320 None needed
6 months US$5,020 None needed
12 months US$16,120 None needed

The fee that brings it to zero is the upfront cost less the contribution so far. For three months: US$3,880 − (US$475 + US$1,025 + US$1,850) = US$3,880 − US$3,350 = US$530.

A minimum term has to reach at least the payback month. For Larkmoor that is four months. A three-month term ends US$530 short. A six-month term ends at US$5,020. The term sets a floor on the months the client owes.

An onboarding fee moves the starting line. Say Larkmoor charges US$1,500 for onboarding and bills it against the onboarding work. The running total starts at −US$3,880 + US$1,500 = −US$2,380. Then:

  • Month 1: −US$2,380 + US$475 = −US$1,905.
  • Month 2: −US$1,905 + US$1,025 = −US$880.
  • Month 3: −US$880 + US$1,850 = US$970.

Payback moves from month 4 to month 3. The part of the month is US$880 ÷ US$1,850 = 0.48. Months to payback fall from 3.29 to 2.48.

A term and a fee work together. A three-month term with a fee of at least US$530 ends at zero or better. Whether a client accepts either is a sales question. Contract wording is for a lawyer.

What moves the payback month

The table reruns the payback with one change each time.

Case Upfront cost Months to payback Payback month
The example above US$3,880 3.29 4
Onboarding takes 60 hours, not 40 US$4,980 3.88 4
Hours settle at 45, not 30 US$3,880 4.32 5
Hours stay at 55 every month US$3,880 8.17 9
One proposal in three is won US$7,240 5.10 6

Twenty more onboarding hours add US$1,100 (20 × US$55) to the upfront cost. They move payback by 0.59 months (3.88 − 3.29). Hours that never settle move it by 4.88 months (8.17 − 3.29). The settling hours matter more than the onboarding hours.

The retainer was priced for about 30 hours a month. At 55 hours it contributes US$475 a month on a US$3,500 fee. Watch the hours inside each month, as how to tell when a retainer is underwater shows. If they stay high, the question moves to when to reprice, rescope or drop a client.

Lost pitches. The base case counts the one proposal Larkmoor won. Suppose it wins one in three, and each proposal takes 24 hours at US$70. Three proposals were written for each client it wins. The pitch cost is 3 × US$1,680 = US$5,040. The upfront cost is US$5,040 + US$2,200 = US$7,240, and payback moves to month 6. Use your own win rate: proposals won ÷ proposals sent over the last 12 months. The simple version shows the best case. The full version shows what winning a client costs. Run both.

Log the hours so month one tells the truth

Log each new client as three projects, each with its own hours and its own cost rate:

  • Pitch: the hours before signing, in the month you worked them, with a fee of 0. If the client does not exist yet, use the prospect's name. If you lose the proposal, the hours stay on that name. They give you your win rate and the cost of lost pitches.
  • Onboarding: the hours after signing, with a fee of 0 until you bill an onboarding fee.
  • Retainer: the monthly fee and its delivery hours.

Keep onboarding out of the retainer. Larkmoor's month 1 shows why. With the 40 onboarding hours inside it, month 1 would read 95 hours and US$3,500 − 95 × US$55 = −US$1,725. The retainer would look badly underwater, when its own delivery left US$475. Separate projects keep the retainer comparable from month to month. The three still add up to the same total.

Your own list: which clients never paid back

Run the same arithmetic over the clients you already have. Start with every client that began in the last 24 months, including those that left. The ones that left are the sample you most need.

Net to date  = contribution to date − upfront cost
Months to go = shortfall ÷ latest month's contribution

Mark each client paid back (net to date zero or more) or left before payback. For a client still active with net below zero, mark it not yet if the latest month is positive, or not at this pace if the latest month is zero or negative.

Here is Larkmoor's list. The veterinary group is the client from the example, 14 months in. The other four are fictional too:

Client Upfront Months Contribution to date Net to date Latest month Status
Veterinary group US$3,880 14 US$23,700 US$19,820 US$1,850 Paid back
Law firm US$4,150 9 US$7,200 US$3,050 US$1,100 Paid back
Furniture retailer US$3,200 3 US$1,050 −US$2,150 Left Left before payback
Software startup US$5,400 11 US$4,950 −US$450 US$600 Not yet
Charity US$2,600 10 US$1,300 −US$1,300 −US$80 Not at this pace
Total US$19,230 US$38,200 US$18,970

The five clients net US$18,970 (US$38,200 − US$19,230). That total looks healthy. But three of the five, 60.0%, have not paid back. The veterinary group's US$19,820 carries the list.

  • Furniture retailer: left after three months, US$2,150 short.
  • Software startup: US$450 ÷ US$600 = 0.75 months to go, if its latest month holds.
  • Charity: its latest month is −US$80. At this pace it never pays back, so it is a reprice or rescope question.

How long is too long? We found no source that gives a good payback period for a client. OpenStax's text says a business compares payback with a maximum it sets itself. Set yours from your own list. If a client on it left within three months, a payback in month four is a risk you carry.

What this method doesn't do

  • It stops at payback. Larkmoor's client that stays 12 months ends at US$16,120. One that leaves in month 4 ends at US$1,320. The same payback month hides both. OpenStax also notes that the method looks only at the time to recover the cost and ignores the time value of money.
  • It counts contribution, not cash. A client that pays 30 days after you invoice pays back in cash later than the table shows. The 20-minute cash runway check covers the cash side.
  • It prices hours at cost. If the pitch hours would otherwise have sat idle, the cash cost is lower. If they pushed out billable work, it is higher.
  • It rests on a forecast. The hours for months 1 to 3 are a guess until you log them.
  • It uses one cost rate for each stage. A mixed team needs a blended rate.
  • It is a management view, not your books. The US accounting standard cited below expenses costs to win a contract if you would have incurred them whether or not you won. The exception is a cost explicitly chargeable to the customer. Its own consulting example expenses the cost of travel to deliver a proposal. Setup work after signing can be recorded as an asset only if it passes three tests. The payback view spreads the cost over months, so your books may treat the same hours differently, and so may your tax return. Your accountant works from the current Codification.
  • It is not tax or legal advice. Ask your accountant how upfront fees and these hours are recorded or taxed. Ask a lawyer about a minimum term or an onboarding fee clause.

Where the tracker fits

The formulas above work in any spreadsheet. The Client Profitability Tracker takes one row per client project per month. A row holds fees billed, credits, external delivery costs, delivery hours and an internal hourly cost. Each row has its own hourly cost, so the pitch row can take US$70 and the onboarding row US$55. It shows contribution before overhead, margin and contribution per delivery hour by client. A negative result stays in the totals. It holds no running total and no payback month, so you add the months up by hand, as in the table above. Entry is manual, and the workbook is tested in Excel 365 for Windows desktop. Like this guide, it stops before overhead.

Independence

Metricvalley is independent. This guide isn't affiliated with, or endorsed by, the Financial Accounting Standards Board. Nothing in this guide is financial, tax or legal advice.

Sources and method

Every figure in the worked example is fictional (Larkmoor Studio). The method is the payback method as the OpenStax text describes it, applied to one client's pitch, onboarding and monthly contribution. The term, fee, sensitivity and client-list cases are Larkmoor's own arithmetic. The accounting points come from the text of ASU 2014-09, which added Subtopic 340-40 to the Codification: paragraphs 25-3 and 25-5, and Example 1 (55-2 to 55-4). It is the version issued in May 2014. Later updates may have changed the wording.

Common questions

How do you work out the payback month for a new client?

Add the pitch and onboarding hours, each priced at your internal hourly cost. Start a running total at that amount below zero. Each month, add the client's contribution: the fee, less outside costs, less delivery hours times your hourly cost. The payback month is the first month the total reaches zero or more.

Should the hours spent on pitches you lost count?

For a full view, yes. If you win one proposal in three, each client you win carries the hours of three proposals. Use your own win rate: proposals won divided by proposals sent over the last 12 months. Counting only the won proposal shows the best case. Run both versions and compare.

How long should a new client take to pay back?

We found no source that gives a figure for agencies. A managerial accounting textbook says a business compares payback with a maximum it sets itself. Set yours from your own client list: how many months clients stayed. An onboarding fee can bring payback forward, and a minimum term can protect it.

How we research, check and update these guides. Found an error? Email [email protected] and we’ll correct it and note the change here.

All guides