Hire or keep using a freelancer? The break-even hours a month
Compare cost per delivered hour, not salary against rate. In the example, a US$72,000 hire costs US$65.17 per delivery hour, and a US$85 freelancer costs less below about 88 hours a month.
You spend a lot with one freelancer every month, and you wonder whether a hire would cost less. Comparing a salary with an hourly rate won't tell you. The two buy different things.
A freelancer is paid for the hours you use. A hire is paid for every working hour, used or not. This guide puts both on cost per delivered hour, then finds the monthly hours at which they cost the same. The example is US, and tax points are general information.
Compare the same unit
An hourly rate and a salary aren't the same unit. A salary covers a whole year, including holidays and time spent on internal work. A freelancer's rate covers one delivered hour.
Convert the hire to cost per delivery hour. The method has a full guide: How to set an internal hourly cost rate. In short, add the on-costs to the salary and divide by the hours the person can spend on client work. Set that rate against the freelancer's rate.
Annual cost = salary + employer taxes + benefits + equipment
Available hours = 2,080 − holidays − paid time off − sick days
Delivery hours = available hours × share of time on client work
Cost per delivery hour = annual cost ÷ delivery hours
Monthly cost of hire = annual cost ÷ 12
Break-even hours = monthly cost of hire ÷ freelancer hourly rate
The break-even is in freelancer hours a month. If you buy fewer hours than that, the freelancer costs less. Above it, the hire costs less, as long as you can fill the hire's hours.
Employer costs on top of salary (US)
Salary is the start. These are the costs a US employer adds. The first two come from the IRS. The rest you estimate.
- Social Security and Medicare. The employer pays 6.2% for Social Security and 1.45% for Medicare, which is 7.65% of pay. The 2026 Social Security wage base is US$184,500, so a salary under that pays the full 7.65% (IRS Topic 751 and Publication 15).
- Federal unemployment tax (FUTA). The Form 940 instructions give a 6.0% rate on the first US$7,000 of each employee's pay, with a credit of up to 5.4% for state unemployment tax paid. Most employers net 0.6%, or US$42 per employee. States whose credit is reduced cost more, so check yours.
- State unemployment tax. The rate and wage base differ by state and by employer. Ask your state unemployment agency for yours.
- Benefits. Health cover, retirement match, paid leave you fund. This is your own estimate.
- Equipment and software used only by that person.
- Left out of the example: workers' compensation insurance, payroll service fees, recruiting fees, and the manager time a hire needs. Add each one that applies to you.
A worked example (fictional)
Fictional example. Ferrow Lane Studio is not a real business. The figures are illustrative and are not a customer result.
Ferrow Lane Studio is a six-person brand and web studio that bills in US dollars. It pays one freelance developer US$85 an hour and is thinking of hiring a developer on a US$72,000 salary. The state unemployment figure and the benefits figure are assumptions, because both vary by state and by plan.
Step 1: the annual cost.
| Item | Calculation | US$ a year |
|---|---|---|
| Salary | 72,000 | |
| Social Security and Medicare | 72,000 × 7.65% | 5,508 |
| Federal unemployment tax | 7,000 × 0.6% | 42 |
| State unemployment tax | assumption | 500 |
| Benefits | assumption | 9,000 |
| Equipment | assumption | 2,500 |
| Total | 89,550 |
Step 2: the delivery hours. A full-time year is 2,080 hours. Take out 88 hours for 11 holidays, 120 hours for 15 days of paid time off and 40 hours for 5 sick days. That leaves 2,080 − 88 − 120 − 40 = 1,832 available hours. The studio expects 75% of them on client work: 1,832 × 75% = 1,374 delivery hours, or 1,374 ÷ 12 = 114.5 a month.
Step 3: cost per delivery hour. US$89,550 ÷ 1,374 = US$65.17. The freelancer costs US$85. On this measure the hire is US$19.83 an hour cheaper, but only for hours that get delivered.
Step 4: the break-even. The hire costs US$89,550 ÷ 12 = US$7,462.50 a month. Divide by the freelancer's US$85: 7,462.50 ÷ 85 = 87.8 hours a month. Below about 88 hours of work a month, keep the freelancer. Above it, the hire costs less, if the studio can fill 114.5 delivery hours.
Step 5: what different amounts of work do. The hire costs US$7,462.50 a month at every level of work. The freelancer costs US$85 for each hour used.
| Hours needed a month | Freelancer | Hire | Hire costs less by | Share of the hire's 114.5 hours used | Hire cost per hour used |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 60 | US$5,100.00 | US$7,462.50 | −US$2,362.50 | 52.4% | US$124.38 |
| 80 | US$6,800.00 | US$7,462.50 | −US$662.50 | 69.9% | US$93.28 |
| 100 | US$8,500.00 | US$7,462.50 | US$1,037.50 | 87.3% | US$74.63 |
| 114.5 | US$9,732.50 | US$7,462.50 | US$2,270.00 | 100.0% | US$65.17 |
At 100 hours a month, the hire saves US$1,037.50 × 12 = US$12,450 a year. At 60 hours it costs US$2,362.50 × 12 = US$28,350 more. Above 114.5 hours the saving stays at US$2,270 a month, and the extra hours still go to the freelancer.
The catch: you pay for 1,374 hours
The table shows the risk. The hire is paid for 1,374 delivery hours whether or not you sell them. The freelancer's cost falls when work does. The hire's cost doesn't.
At 100 hours a month the hire looks good: US$74.63 for each hour used. If the work drops to 60 hours, the same person costs US$124.38 for each hour used. That is more than the freelancer's US$85.
So test the hire against your quietest recent months, not your busiest. How to set a realistic utilization target shows how to count the hours a person can really deliver. Hire only on work you can see ahead, such as a retainer that runs for months. A retainer you could lose in one call is a weak base.
Two checks keep it honest:
- Count the steady hours. Use the lowest month in the last six, not the average.
- Check the skills. A hire does one person's work. If the freelancer covers design, code and QA, one hire won't replace all three.
Ramp-up months and the cash they need
A new hire doesn't deliver full hours at once. You pay the full cost from the first month and may keep paying the freelancer for the rest of the work.
Suppose Ferrow Lane's demand is steady at 100 hours a month. The hire delivers 50% of 114.5 hours for the first two months: 114.5 × 50% = 57.25 hours. The freelancer covers the rest.
- Cost in a ramp month. The hire is US$7,462.50. The freelancer covers 100 − 57.25 = 42.75 hours, which is 42.75 × US$85 = US$3,633.75. The total is US$11,096.25.
- Freelancer only. 100 × US$85 = US$8,500.
- Extra cash per ramp month. US$11,096.25 − US$8,500 = US$2,596.25. Over two months, that is US$5,192.50.
- Payback. After ramp-up the hire saves US$1,037.50 a month. The ramp cost comes back in month 8, because 6 × US$1,037.50 = US$6,225 is more than US$5,192.50, and 5 × US$1,037.50 = US$5,187.50 is not.
The payback leaves out recruiting costs, which would push it later. The cash is real. Cash runway for small agencies shows how to check whether your cash covers it.
When a freelancer looks like an employee
The more you use one freelancer, the more they can look like staff. This is general information, not advice on your case.
The IRS describes the common-law test in three groups of facts: behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship. Does the company control what the worker does and how? Does the worker control the business side of the job? Are there benefits, a written contract, or work that continues and is key to the business? The IRS says businesses must weigh all of these factors (IRS, Independent contractor (self-employed) or employee?).
If your freelancer works set hours, on your tools, under your direction, for most of the year, ask your accountant or a lawyer before the next payment. The IRS page covers federal tax. Other rules, and state rules, can differ.
What this doesn't do
- It isn't tax, payroll or legal advice. Ask your accountant about payroll costs and your lawyer about worker classification.
- It uses an assumed US$500 of state unemployment tax and US$9,000 of benefits. Your figures will differ, and so will your state's rules.
- It leaves out workers' compensation, payroll fees, recruiting fees and the manager time a hire needs.
- It treats the freelancer's rate as the whole cost. Your own time to brief and review their work is not counted.
- It assumes 75% of available time goes to client work and that you can fill it. The break-even moves with that share.
- It measures cost only. Skills, quality, culture and how fast you can find a good person are not in the numbers.
- It stops before overhead, and it doesn't forecast demand.
A calculator for this
The Project Quote Calculator builds a loaded cost rate for each role from pay, on-costs, leave and the share of time on client work. It also takes a contractor's hourly or day rate, so an employee and a freelancer can sit side by side. It shows a blended team rate for comparison.
It doesn't model a hire's ramp-up or break-even hours, so work those out with the formulas above. Entry is manual, and the workbook is tested in Excel 365 for Windows desktop. The formulas in this guide work in any spreadsheet.
Independence
Metricvalley is independent. This guide isn't affiliated with, or endorsed by, the Internal Revenue Service. Nothing in it is tax, payroll or legal advice.
Sources
- Internal Revenue Service, Topic no. 751, Social Security and Medicare withholding rates (page updated Sep 24, 2026), read Nov 6, 2026.
- Internal Revenue Service, Publication 15 (2026), (Circular E), Employer's Tax Guide (page updated Apr 30, 2026), read Nov 6, 2026.
- Internal Revenue Service, Instructions for Form 940 (2025) (page updated Apr 30, 2026), read Nov 6, 2026.
- Internal Revenue Service, Independent contractor (self-employed) or employee? (page updated May 19, 2026), read Nov 6, 2026.
Every other figure in this guide comes from the fictional worked example (Ferrow Lane Studio). The benefits, state unemployment and equipment amounts, the 75% share and the two-month ramp at 50% are assumptions of the example.
Common questions
At what monthly freelancer spend is it cheaper to hire?
Divide the hire's total yearly cost by 12, then by the freelancer's hourly rate. That gives the monthly hours at which the two cost the same. Above it, the hire costs less only if you can fill the hire's delivery hours. In the example, that is 87.8 hours of freelancer work a month against 114.5 delivery hours to fill.
What does an employee cost on top of salary in the US?
At least the employer share of Social Security (6.2%) and Medicare (1.45%), federal unemployment tax, and state unemployment tax. Add benefits and equipment if you provide them. Insurance, payroll fees and recruiting come on top. State rules differ, so ask your accountant what applies to your payroll.
Can I hire a freelancer full time and still call them a contractor?
The label doesn't decide it. The IRS looks at behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship. Set hours, your tools and your direction point toward an employee. This is general information, so ask your accountant or a lawyer before you rely on a contractor arrangement.
How we research, check and update these guides. Found an error? Email [email protected] and we’ll correct it and note the change here.